Mac Blu-ray Player Lets Macs Display Blu-ray Movies
Review of Mac Blu-ray Player v2.4.0
- 2012.07.24 - Tip Jar
The Mac Blu-ray Player for Mac has been around now for a little over a year, but until the UJ-267, which I recently reviewed, and the UJ-167, which both arrived mere weeks ago, there were no internal Blu-ray drives for the Unibody MacBook Pro. This limited Blu-ray playback to external drives on these late model portables, which needless to say isn't an ideal solution if you are traveling.
Obviously, for desktops, an external solution isn't as big of a problem, so with that said for the purposes of my discussion and review of Macgo Blu-ray player I would like to focus on the experience it provides users of portable machines. My test machine is a 2.3 GHz 17" Core i7 (quad core) February 2011 MacBook Pro, and the version of Macgo Blu-ray Player as of this writing is version 2.4.0.
The 17" Unibody MacBook Pro is an ideal candidate for both internal Blu-ray drives and the Macgo Blu-ray player. The 1920 x 1200 screen looks amazing when watching or working with full 1080p video. Now equipped with a Matshita UJ-267 internal Blu-ray drive, my MacBook Pro can now take full advantage of watching my Blu-ray discs courtesy of Macgo's Blu-ray player.
Early Potential and Portability for Mac Blu-ray Player
Since Macgo's initial release last year, pre-Unibody 17" MacBook Pros running a Core 2 Duo could have potentially been early adopters of internal Blu-ray drives and the Macgo Blu-ray player, giving the full convenience of portable Blu-ray playback on the MacBook Pro since the first version of Macgo's player. Several of these Core 2 Duo MacBook Pros meet the recommended 2.4 GHz Core 2 Duo minimum specs for the Mac Blu-ray Player and, in addition, are able to take a 12.7mm slot loading optical drive (12.7mm slot-loading Blu-ray drives such as the Panasonic UJ-225 have been on the market since late 2010).
Pre-Unibody 17" MacBook Pros have been able to take advantage of both internal Blu-ray drives and Mac Blu-ray Player since their respective introductions due to earlier (non-unibody) 17" MacBook Pros being able to accommodate 12.7mm height optical drives.
Unfortunately, 12.7mm optical drives just won't fit into other portable Macs besides the aforementioned 17" machines. The internal clearance for a 12.7mm optical drive just didn't exist, and these Macs needed to wait until the brand new 9.5mm drives arrived to also take advantage of an internal Blu-ray solution. This gave Macgo Blu-ray Player a limited audience initially for those who wanted convenient Blu-ray on the go, but with the release of the new 9.5mm slot-loading Blu-ray drives, the doors have completely opened for every portable Mac to have an internal Blu-ray drive. Just don't forget the recommended minimum specification of a 2.4 GHz Core 2 Duo or you may not experience ideal performance for Blu-ray playback.
Mac Blu-ray Player: The First and Only of Its Kind
With drives and portability aside momentarily, Macgo Blu-ray player remains the first and only easy way to play commercial Blu-ray discs in Mac OS X, whether with a Mac desktop (which would be more ideal for external drives and larger full-sized internal desktop drives) or a MacBook Pro. I am fully impressed with how far the technology has come since its introduction over a year ago, making it a viable purchase for anyone using a Mac who may want to take advantage of Blu-ray playback.
Originally reported as somewhat buggy last year, the folks at Macgo have been hard at work improving and perfecting this product. As of late, there seems to be a stronger than ever effort to continue updating the software as seen in the version history with the numerous recent updates (currently at version 2.4.0 as of this writing).
Features That Keep Improving
Mac Blu-ray Player offers full no-frills playback of the main feature. The menus and most special features are not supported at this time, but this is a small gripe considering that most people just want to watch the movie. During the main feature playback, the sound is crisp, and the picture quality is amazing - obviously much more impressive than DVD or Standard Definition Digital (more on that in a bit).
Social media integration is another thing that Macgo would like to take advantage of when watching a film. You can make a Tweet from within the application while the movie plays. You are also supposed to be able to post to your Facebook wall. Unfortunately, I was unable to see any posts to my wall on behalf of the application after granting the proper permissions to the App, typing up a wall post, and getting the success message. The good news here is that in versions prior to 2.4, I was not having success with Twitter integration either, but it appears that this has been addressed, and Twitter posting works just fine now. Fixing some of the social media integration is a good example of the concerted efforts of Macgo, continuing to take steps in the right direction towards becoming a complete and full-featured application with all the trimmings!
Last worth mentioning are numerous setting changes from aspect ratio to video fine-tuning to closed captions, etc. There is even a built-in snapshot option for getting a quick still of the video you are watching to make some fun pictures. This adds to the overall package by giving you some customization depending on the screen type you may have.
Still a Ways to Go...
Mac Blu-ray Player is quite good for what it's worth, but it still has a ways to go before I could give it a higher recommendation. I'm sure that continued updates will address the remaining issues, but as of this writing there are a few things that Macgo needs to prioritize that are advertised functions that do not yet work properly:
- One of the features advertised to work is the ability to play back a Blu-ray, DVD, or other video file from your Mac and watch it (streaming via Safari) on the iPad using a technology called AirPlayX. I was unable to get this feature to work in either OS X 10.6.8 Snow Leopard or 10.7.4 Lion using this machine and my Retina Display 16 GB iPad, which were both connected to the same local wireless network. Enabling AirX (short for Airplay X in the "Tools" menu within the Macgo Blu-ray Player) before inserting a disc or playing an .mkv backup of one of my discs provided the same result: The Macgo Blu-ray player would hang, requiring a force-quit. When a disc was inserted after AirX was started, in addition to it not launching properly, it would also cause the disc to not properly dismount, requiring a restart (remounting via Disk Utility did not remedy nor did a force eject attempt after this issue). This issue may be isolated to the New (Retina) iPad, as I don't have other iOS devices to test on, but nonetheless it would be nice to take advantage of this streaming capability.
- When ejecting the disc from the Macgo menu, I also have experienced problems with the disc dismounting from the desktop and not ejecting, causing a conflict similar to what happened when I attempted to use AirX, also requiring a restart. Simply quitting the application or closing the window when you are done watching (rather than ejecting from the Macgo menu) and then ejecting from the Finder seems to be the best way to remedy this for now (at least on a MacBook Pro running Snow Leopard or Lion as I tested).
- Full menu and special feature support would be very nice. Being able to have the Macgo Blu-ray player work exactly the same as a standalone unit would be ideal. Adding BD-Live would also be a welcome added convenience that would work while you are connected online.
- Facebook integration needs addressed. As mentioned, this didn't work for me. It's nice that Twitter now seems functional in version 2.4.0, but fixing Facebook would make the social integration tools even better, especially with a thumbnail of the film you are watching attached to the message.
Wish List for Improvements
When any of the current minor issues with Mac Blu-ray Player are taken care of, it will clearly make a fairly competent piece of software excellent. I'm sure Macgo is hard at work doing exactly that. With that in mind, I would like to pose a few other things I believe could enhance future versions even more (Full Menu and disc support are a no-brainer):
- Displaying the resolution currently being sent to the monitor, and the ability to toggle the resolution of video that can be upconverted (example: DVD upconversion to 1080i, 720p, or 1080p depending on the monitor's capabilities).
- The anti-aliasing filters do not seem to do anything at all. I tried to use the filters with a DVD, a Blu-ray, and a digital .mkv backup and did not see a difference in picture quality with any of these using every anti-aliasing filter available. Perhaps it's hard to notice on the built-in 17" 1920 x 1200 display of the MacBook Pro and would be more evident if the video were sent to a larger display. A better explanation of these filters and what they intend to accomplish would probably be useful in future updates.
- A rating system for the films would be fun. Perhaps a link to Rotten Tomatoes or IMDB with the ability to link what you are watching on Macgo to those sites - or even a review system that is entirely independent on Macgo's site generated by content watched by users.
A picture is still worth 1000 words: The difference is just as clear here between DVD and Blu-ray as it is in the comparison of the iTunes Digital Copy and Blu-ray images from the motion picture 2012 in my review of the UJ-267. Look at the particle effects and the light shimmer on the water surface in this image from these stills from the 2011 motion picture Thor. It is evident which one is the DVD and which one is the Blu-ray.
The Bottom Line
Blu-ray is truly amazing and is the only current standard for store bought, commercially developed HD video on physical media. Sure, there are lots of options in the cloud for streaming services (Vudu, Netflix, and Hulu Plus, to name a few) that can also put out some excellent HD visuals, but when you don't have a live Internet connection and want to enjoy HD movies on the go, Blu-ray is the best solution.
Purchasing Blu-rays and using a Blu-ray drive with your Mac (especially an internal drive such as the UJ-267 or UJ-167 with the MacBook Pro) with Mac Blu-ray Player can provide you with endless entertainment possibilities in gorgeous HD resolutions. The 1920 x 1200 display of the now discontinued 17" MacBook Pro is ideal for enjoying those videos.
Mac Blu-ray Player already works well for what it does. I recommend this product for anyone with a Blu-ray drive and a collection of Blu-ray discs. Despite the fact that it's the only solution that makes playing Blu-ray discs simple on the Mac, the Macgo team does not seem to be resting on its laurels and is making constant improvements to the product. As of now without any other bug fixes, I can say that it's absolutely worth the current purchase price.
The internal drives I've discussed combined with the Macgo Blu-ray Player create an elegant solution for Blu-ray viewing on the go and will allow you to play your discs and make back-up digital HD files. Just don't forget that the digital back-up files you create from your Blu-rays are quite large, taking up to 25 GB of space from a single-layer Blu-ray and up to 50 GB from a dual-layer disc.
Mac Blu-ray Player system requirements: 2.4 GHz Intel Core 2 Duo running Mac OS X 10.5, 512 MB RAM, 250 MB available hard drive space, internal or external (USB 2.0 or FireWire 400) Blu-ray drive. Mac Blu-ray Player is on sale for $39.95 (normally $59.95) through July 29, 2012.
Dan Bashur lives in central Ohio with his wife and children. He uses various PowerPC G3 and G4 Macs running Tiger and Leopard. Besides finding new uses for Macs and other tech, Dan enjoys writing (fantasy novel series in the works), is an avid gamer, and a member of Sony's Gamer Advisor Panel. You can read more of Dan Bashur's work on ProjectGamers.com, where he contributes regular articles about the PSP, classic gaming, and ways you can use Sony gaming hardware with your Mac.
Recent Apple, Tech, and Gaming Columns
- 12" PowerBook G4 to the Rescue Once Again, 2013.01.28. With the much larger MacBook Pro in for service, it was a joy to rediscover how useful this old PowerBook remains.
- Remembering the Hi-Res PowerBook G4, 2012.10.29. The last generation of PowerBooks had high resolution screens, potent graphics, and dual-layer SuperDrives.
- $90 USB 2.0 Blu-ray Drive Also Works Inside a Mac mini, 2012.09.05. The Blu-ray drive inside this USB 2.0 enclosure transplants easily into a pre-2009 Core 2 Duo Mac mini, where it works like a charm.
- More in the Apple, Tech, and Gaming index.
Links for the Day
- Mac of the Day: Mac LC II, introduced 1992.03.23. The LC gets 4 MB base RAM, gains virtual memory thanks to 68030 CPU.
- May 19 in LEM history: 99: Student Bill of Rights - 01: First Apple Stores - 03: Upgraded beige G3 problems - 04: The Mac legacy - More for Mac users in superstores than many realize - 06: Smart design make the MacBook a winner - 08: Top 10 freeware - My first iMac
- Support Low End Mac
Recent Content on Low End Mac
- World Book Encyclopedia 2012 DVD, Tommy Thomas, Reviews, 2013.03.05. "You may be asking yourself, in an age of Wikipedia and instant information, is World Book still relevant?"
- Vintage Computer Festival SouthEast, April 20-21, 2013, Simon Royal, Mac Spectrum, 2013.02.25. Old Apple gear and old PCs.
- iMessage: The Ultimate Messaging Service?, Simon Royal, Mac Spectrum, 2013.02.21. In most ways, Apple's iMessage is far superior to BlackBerry Messenger.
- More links in our archive.
- Best Mac mini Deals
- Best 13" MacBook Pro Deals
- Best Intel iMac Deals
- Best iPod touch Deals
- Best iPhone Deals
- Best iPod nano Deals
- Best iPod classic Deals
- Best Apple TV Prices
- More deals in our archive.
Low End Mac Reader Specials
Cult of Mac
Shrine of Apple
The Mac Observer
Accelerate Your Mac
The Vintage Mac Museum
Mac Driver Museum
System 6 Heaven
System 7 Today
the pickle's Low-End Mac FAQ