Round USB Mouse
Dan Knight - 1999.07.09
Second Class Macs are Apple's somewhat compromised hardware designs. For the most part, they're not really bad - simply designs that didn't meet their full potential. (On our rating scale, the more brown apples, the worse the hardware.)
In the history of mouse design, none have earned more scorn than the round USB mouse the Apple ships with the iMac and USB Power Macs.
From an aesthetic standpoint, the puck-mouse nicely complements the curvaceous iMac, but from a user perspective, it's incredibly frustrating to move the mouse one way and have the cursor go another simply because there is absolutely no tactile feedback to let you know you're not holding it straight.
All I know is that not a single one remains in use among all the iMacs and Blue G3s at work. They go in the equipment closet with the spare ADB cables, power cords, etc.
On the positive side, the round mouse has driven an industry of third-party solutions: USB mice, shells for the Apple mouse, and mouse alternatives such as trackballs. After all, if there are around 2 million of these inexcusably un-ergonomic mice out there, that's one very lucrative market.
I've used a lot of mice over the past 15 years: Apple's chunky mouse from the original Mac, the rectangular ADB mouse, their teardrop ADB mouse, the Kensington TurboMouse, the Contour UniMouse, and still others back in my DOS days. There wasn't a single one you could grab wrong without immediately sensing it.
- To those who say you have to learn how to hold it in your palm or with your fingertips, I remind you that Apple has always promoted the mouse as an intuitive input device. Grab it, move it, see what it does, and work with it. A mouse should not require training.
Back to the drawing board, Apple.
NOTE: Apple did go back to the drawing board, releasing a modified round mouse in mid-1999. The new mouse has a dimple on the mouse button, giving more tactile feedback if the mouse is significantly misoriented. A smaller dimple or more ergonomic mouse would be nice, but it's a step in the right direction.
Best of all, at Macworld Expo New York in July 2000, Apple replaced the puck mouse with a gorgeous optical mouse - and it wasn't round.
Low End Mac Reader Specials
Cult of Mac
Shrine of Apple
The Mac Observer
Accelerate Your Mac
The Vintage Mac Museum
Mac Driver Museum
System 6 Heaven
System 7 Today
the pickle's Low-End Mac FAQ