Apple Losing Ground in Education
A Teacher's Perspective from the Trenches
Those of us who have been around for a while, we remember.
We remember when the only computer worth having in the classroom was an Apple II. We remember when Windows 1.0 came out with its laughable interface. We remember bringing our own computers from home out of sheer frustration with the lack of resources provided by our districts.
Before there were IT committees, tech councils, or "standards," we were there.
And now we're being assailed from all sides. Young teachers arrive having never used a Mac. Consultants gently guide purchases toward the Wintel hegemony. This week, one lab converts from Mac to PC. Next week, the library ditches a bunch of G3 Blue and Whites in favor of Dells - when the Blue and Whites were often the only machines working.
If you look at the decision making process at a typical two-platform school, you find that the Macs are increasingly relegated to enclaves where teachers, like myself, make a concerted effort to concentrate them in one place. The PCs are installed where younger teachers or teachers connected to business want to stay with what they find comfortable.
In our school, the Byzantine hardware purchasing process and committee-based decision making has resulted in some bizarre decisions.
- The newspaper ditched its collection of aging 5200s in exchange for some PCs, despite the fact that everyone acknowledges that the Mac is the computer of choice in publishing circles.
- The most common use for our 500 MHz CD-RW iMacs is as a teacher workhorse machine - including accessing a critical attendance program through an NT server that makes the iMac feel slow as molasses.
- Classes in creative settings, such as Web design and art, have abandoned the platform entirely in favor of low-priced Wintel machines.
- The science teachers who use computers use Macs - because they are inheriting the displaced machines. Several have voiced a preference for a PC-based lab, but since what I do I do for fun, not for pay, they can do that themselves if they want.
- Our award-winning video production class is practically all Wintel due to the high cost of Final Cut Pro and lack of options in iMovie.
The only really outstanding example of Mac use left is one teacher who teaches a slew of courses including Web design, plus our small fleet of iBook laptop carts - which I have to prepare and maintain, because if I didn't do it, they'd suffer from an incomplete and inconsistent configuration. There are a couple of science labs using Macs, but right now they could kind of go either way, depending on what kind of machines become available.
Sometimes I feel like I stepped through a wormhole and live in an anti-universe, with everything the same, but backwards. Like the budget, for example.
Now that California's budget has tanked and the Digital High School grant has evaporated, we have exactly one-fifth of an FTE dedicated to computer issues, plus some tech time on a weekly basis from the district. That brings questions to mind.
Will the Dells (running Windows 2000) last indefinitely, or will they disintegrate faster than the iMacs, due to their easy-open-stolen-from-Apple design? Will students open up the computers and pop out the easy-bake RAM chips? Will they be able to successfully circumvent the PC security logins more effectively than they can hack a Mac? Will they steal the mice because they work at home? Will there be some rampant virus that slips by the district's proxy server, infecting the network? Will the Macs be rejected by people who prefer to use floppy drives?
No one knows the answers. One thing I do know: School districts do not like to be early adopters. We are firmly seated in OS 9 for the time being, so any possible benefits of Jaguar are not ours to partake.
This is not helped by the fact that education users do not get much of a break on Apple hardware or software. Fifty bucks off a $1,000 computer is pretty much a joke when the competition discounts by half or more.
Apple's education market share is slipping primarily because the teaching workforce is aging and the younger teachers have no compelling reason or brand loyalty to fall back on. Districts are building real IT support structures - some more successfully than others - which prefer to have a single platform to support because it is simpler for them to comprehend.
Unlike the past, in many cases you're not even allowed to diagnose and repair machines yourself. Dynamic and motivated teachers are not able to control how the technology money that everyone is being forced to use is spent. When you were the only teacher using computers, you got a grant and bought what you wanted. When early technology budgets were established, they asked you because you were the only one with significant experience.
Now everyone must have computers - whether they want them or not - and the kind of decision making that goes into that sort of a purchase is entirely different than one centered on creating the best solution for a specific problem at hand.
The most compelling reasons for using a Mac used to be ease of networking with AppleTalk, compatibility and upgradeability of systems from many different years of development, and iDisk. None of these reasons are positive contributions any longer; even the iDisk that we promised would negate the lack of a hard drive has been taken away (not that it ever worked through our proxy servers anyway).
Our head IT guy says, "Apple has nothing to offer me," and the considerations of my little classroom are not strong enough to override that in today's budget climate. All I can do is look out for myself; convincing others has become difficult, contentious, and moved beyond the scope of what is appropriate for colleagues to do for each other.
Our district suffers from a creeping conversion, not the centralized proclamation of fealty to the Wintel hegemony that you sometimes read about. Officially, we are a cross-platform district and will be for the indefinite future. Wintels can be chosen (and are), but when decisions are made in situations about which no one cares, Wintels move in by fiat, and no one can challenge the fait accompli when you walk in and see a sea of black Dellmentias filling a room.
Inch by inch, step by step, things are creeping toward the Dark Side.
Now that I've painted a gloomy picture for you, let me try to add a glimmer of light to the landscape.
If you are a Mac advocate, like myself, then you are probably using computers in the classroom for more than just "Internet research." Your students are probably creating things, making more than just a study of the vendor's operating system or a favorite application suite. If that's the case, showcase the work. Don't hide it.
- Let people see what's possible using your Mac.
- If you are offered a seat on a technology committee, take it. If you aren't offered, ask.
- Help others with their computers.
I will supply any science teacher who asks with functional Macs to build the beginnings of a computer lab. I have more machines than I can use right now, and there are teachers who could use more machines in our school. They're beginning to get fired up about it, but just beginning.
Just in case you're thinking it, I have to tell you our district will not transfer even unused machines outside of a school, let alone the district. Long story.
And if you get a grant that covers hardware, buy a Mac.
It wouldn't hurt if you read Low End Mac and sent links to our articles to all your friends.
is a longtime Mac user. He was using digital sensors on Apple II computers in the 1980's and has networked computers in his classroom since before the internet existed. In 2006 he was selected at the California Computer Using Educator's teacher of the year. His students have used NASA space probes and regularly participate in piloting new materials for NASA. He is the author of two books and numerous articles and scientific papers. He currently teaches astronomy and physics in California, where he lives with his twin sons, Jony and Ben.< And there's still a Mac G3 in his classroom which finds occasional use.
Recent Mac Lab Reports
- Macs in Space: Curiosity Rover Based on G3 Processor, 2012.08.07. When choosing a CPU for space missions, NASA looks for reliability above all else - and NASA chose a PowerPC G3 as the brains of the Curiosity rover.
- Bike Across the Country While in Your Basement, 2012.06.25. By linking your exercise bike to a PC running Google Maps Street View, you can virtually bike across the country.
- Microsoft Word 2004 vs. iWork Pages 1.0 for writing a book, 2008.01.10. Microsoft Word is great for technical writing, powerful yet slow, while Pages lets you concentrate on just writing, making it great for novels.
- More in the Mac Lab Report index.
Links for the Day
- Mac of the Day: Quadra 950, introduced 1992.05.18. Apple's huge tower has 5 NuBus slots and runs a 33 MHz 68040 processor.
- May 18 in LEM history: 92: Quadra 950 - 99: OS 8.6 more stable - 00: What can you squeeze into a compact Mac? - 01: Friendly LC 500s - Leaving Win2k behind - 05: OS X 10.4.1 update - A new PowerBook with Tiger - Tiger: Lots to like, but some annoyances - 06: 400K floppy click of death - I wish Apple were more like Microsoft - 07: 9.9% notebook market share
- Support Low End Mac
Recent Content on Low End Mac
- World Book Encyclopedia 2012 DVD, Tommy Thomas, Reviews, 2013.03.05. "You may be asking yourself, in an age of Wikipedia and instant information, is World Book still relevant?"
- Vintage Computer Festival SouthEast, April 20-21, 2013, Simon Royal, Mac Spectrum, 2013.02.25. Old Apple gear and old PCs.
- iMessage: The Ultimate Messaging Service?, Simon Royal, Mac Spectrum, 2013.02.21. In most ways, Apple's iMessage is far superior to BlackBerry Messenger.
- More links in our archive.
- Best Mac mini Deals
- Best 13" MacBook Pro Deals
- Best Intel iMac Deals
- Best iPod touch Deals
- Best iPhone Deals
- Best iPod nano Deals
- Best iPod classic Deals
- Best Apple TV Prices
- More deals in our archive.
Low End Mac Reader Specials
Cult of Mac
Shrine of Apple
The Mac Observer
Accelerate Your Mac
The Vintage Mac Museum
Mac Driver Museum
System 6 Heaven
System 7 Today
the pickle's Low-End Mac FAQ