Hi Low Enders! It’s the Bash man again, with another happy episode of trials and tribulations getting my Mac Pro 2,1 in a stable triple boot state (queue crickets, darkness, and crackling campfire as you roast marshmallows and read on).
Even 14 years into its existence, I’m finding my Mac Pro 1,1 to be one of the most incredible investments I’ve ever made. For under $400, I have been able to transform what was once a $200 to $300 investment about 5 years back as a stock Mac Pro 1,1 (albeit with a couple initial upgrades such as a Solid State Drive and a couple better than stock GPUs such as a flashed Radeon 5670 and fanless GeForce GT 210). I’ve upgraded away though and have really made this thing a beast by adding the following since the initial purchase from a LEM swap lister:
- Dual Xeon 5365 CPUs and firmware flash to a 2,1
- Doubled RAM to 32 GB from 16
- Added an extra SSD to serve as a dedicated Windows Boot Camp Disk
- Added a GeForce 980Ti and most recently a Radeon HD2600 XT to my repertoire of GPUs
- Secondary optical updated to an LG BD-XL/DVD-RW
The only drawback is that the 1,1 and 2,1 max out unofficially at Mac OS X 10.11 El Capitan (and you need to avoid installing a specific security update for El Capitan which breaks the 1,1 and 2,1 from booting into El Capitan any longer), but how can one complain running 14-year old hardware that was supposed to have reached the end of its line at Mac OS X 10.7 Lion, which was released 9 years ago?! I have Mac OS X 10.10 Yosemite on mine, which is perfectly stable for now and worlds ahead of Lion. At the very least, Google’s Chrome browser (version 81.x as of this writing) is still supported for now on Yosemite, as well as Office 365 (Office 2016), along with a myriad of other things that should keep Yosemite somewhat relevant for a few more years.
Getting an unofficial version of OS X on the Mac Pro is not the point of this article though, as much has already been written about hacking Mac OS versions beyond Lion on the 1,1 and 2,1. The point of this article is how on Earth can one get the absolute most out of this machine in a Tri-Boot scenario of OSes that have different fundamental requirements?
So how did I do it personally to get the absolute most out of it with three different OSes that have different needs? I have Yosemite and Mac OS X 10.6 Snow Leopard on one SSD and Windows 10 (64-bit) on its own SSD for Boot Camp (getting 64-bit versions of Windows also requires a bit of a hack but is completely stable). From the point I got my OSes where I wanted, sure – I could have just used one EFI supported GPU and called it a day, but that would not do. How can you expect to play modern games and squeeze the most life out of your applications with an official Apple AMD Radeon (X1900, HD 2600 XT, 5770/5870, etc.) or Apple NVidia card (7300, 8800, GT120, etc)? While these were all competent GPUs in their day and generate boot screens, they are now getting too long in the tooth for many things – especially for use with gaming and some of the most recent web applications. That’s where the GeForce 980Ti comes in. Fellow LEM writer Mark Sokolovsky chronicles how to get a GeForce 980Ti installed in his Mac Pro 2,1 in his article Install an Nvidia GeForce GTX 980 TI in Your Mac Pro 1,1 or 2,1.
The GeForce 980Ti is the perfect GPU upgrade for the Mac Pro 2,1 when you’re running Yosemite and it’s current unofficial maximum (El Capitan), since with dual quad-core 3.0 GHz Xeons for the Mac Pro 2,1 and this GPU, you then have a very powerful machine on a budget that is not only competent for modern Windows gaming and even VR (my son has a refurbished Oculus Rift on the way that we’ll all check out soon that I can write about – Mark also did this with his 2,1). The GTX 980Ti requires Yosemite, but cannot go beyond High Sierra (10.13.x) due to no NVidia driver support beyond that point, but that point is moot on the Mac Pro 1,1 and 2,1 since El Capitan is the maximum, so you’ll be running a 980Ti in Yosemite or El Capitan if you want to use it on a Mac Pro 1,1 or 2,1. Great power like that is not without its own drawbacks though. This card eats up both of your PCIe auxiliary power taps on the Mac Pro logic board, and while there are ways around this to get more power taps, it does require a bit of extra work and I was content to just use other GPUs that did not require additional aux power taps. Additionally, since the 980Ti will not work in Snow Leopard and since both aux PCIe taps are used by the 980Ti, that limits the list somewhat of what GPUs you can use with Snow Leopard in tandem. I settled on the Radeon HD 2600XT for boot screens, but also left my flashed 5670 in place, since it’s several times faster than the 2600 and *drumroll* supported completely under Snow Leopard (just no boot screens), while only needing PCIe bus power (albeit with no boot screen), but I have gotten around the aesthetics of that easily.
The biggest challenge and hurdle initially for me to get this all working properly was with my workflow. I was using dual Apple ADC Cinema displays at 1920×1200 as my main displays initially via the ADC to DVI powered converters and did not get boot screens at all between the 980Ti and flashed Radeon 5670. If I wanted to move between Snow Leopard and Yosemite or between Windows and anything else, I had to zap the PRAM every time. This surely was not good on the PRAM battery or the long term health of the system, so I was searching for a better solution and found that the Radeon HD 2600 XT (stock card from the Mac Pro 3,1) was both bus powered and fully supported in Snow Leopard and Yosemite. I also initially added a third display when moving to the HD 2600 as a third card – a Dell 2007FP (4:3 aspect) at 1600×1200 so I could get boot screens and keep it isolated.
I then added the Apple Cinema displays to my resurrected dual head DVI KVM (IOGear Miniview GCS1644), which was fixed by a stroke of luck of simply replacing the PSU (it had died a few months ago and I set aside). Unfortunately, since adding the HD 2600 and KVM back into the mix, I ran into all kinds of stability issues. My goal was to split off the Apple Displays into 2 viewable sets of 4 “displays” on the KVM (dual outputs of HDMI and DVI from the GTX 980Ti) on one set of inputs on the KVM and dual outputs from the flashed 5670 (again HDMI and DVI) on another set of inputs on the KVM and again – an isolated input from the Radeon 2600 on the Dell display (I also tried with the third input from the 5670 via VGA on the Dell). This would all prove to work in Snow Leopard just fine and it would work in Windows 10 perfectly with any combination of the GPUs being actively displayed, but almost every single time the 980Ti had displays plugged in and when I had the NVidia drivers in Yosemite being loaded at boot (to enable the 980Ti), it would crash or go into a boot loop or would simply revert to Snow Leopard or Windows.
I tried a myriad of adapters and connection types. At first I thought I had pinned it down to the fact that the Cinema displays used single link DVI and I had a mix of single link DVI, dual link DVI and HDMI cables to adapters running, but that theory was short lived as that too wound up failing, so it had to be the KVM right? Nope – even connecting displays directly proved to cause issues (unless you only connected one display per GPU). The only way around it that was foolproof with multiple screens and multiple GPUs in play was to unplug the display connectors from the 980Ti, boot up using the option key to bring up the boot menu from the HD 2600 (both ATI cards could function with the NVidia driver loaded) and then reconnect the 980Ti to the desired number of displays using any connection desired after boot sequence completed. Not an ideal solution either (slightly better most likely than zapping PRAM every time for several scenarios), but not very seamless. So what does a die hard gamer do?
I abandoned the dual display concept, which I do like to have at times and went big… real big (and also gained/upgraded in several other areas by making this swap). I wound up moving my 50″ Pioneer 101FD Elite (9.5G Kuro) to the office from the gaming loft. It’s one of the finest plasma displays ever made and quite frankly, I’m very pleased with the decision.
No more glitches during boot and with the Radeon HD2600 XT (dual link DVI-D connection), flashed Radeon 5670 (HDMI) and 980Ti (HDMI) all on dedicated inputs, I have all bases covered. I just switch the inputs based on what I want to do. During boot if I need to change OSes, all I have to do is select the input on the Pioneer with the 2600HD connected to it to get the boot screen. When I want to play games or do certain things in Snow Leopard that need more power, or if I wanted to boot with Mac Drivers in Yosemite, I simply select the input with the flashed 5670 and when I’m booting into Yosemite with NVidia drivers loaded or Windows 10, I just select the input with the 980Ti connected. It all works perfectly and without mirroring needed! Since the display settings are saved, the proper primary displays will work under each of their respective OSes until the PRAM dies or if I have to reset the PRAM. I even have a spare VGA connection that I could add the MDD G4 or Cube to.
I took the KVM and Cinema displays out of the mix completely. I put one of the 23″ ADC Cinema displays and connected directly via ADC to my G4 Cube equipped with Radeon 7500 (I had a 17″ ADC studio on it). I then traded out the 17″ studio that was with the Cube with the one in the loft that had seen better years (it had some bruising), and lastly moved the second Cinema display to the spot in the loft where the Pioneer plasma was, which will allow me to make that space a little cleaner for now.
At any rate, as they say, when you get lemons, make Lemonade (find another angle and way around when it doesn’t go your way – you might surprise yourself and actually gain a lot more out of the deal). While my plasma is no longer in the gaming loft, the Cinema display is for now and should serve a purpose. I’m very happy with the new setups now and will be taking a break just to enjoy them! Stay safe and stay busy looking for new ways to get the most of your Apple gear! All the best!