Dan Knight - 2005.03.28

With no apologies whatsoever to Microsoft's Six Tips for Buying an MP3 Player with Flash Memory, the Lite Side presents

Seven Tips for Buying an MP3 Player

If you're the type of person who's on the go all the time and wants to jam to your favorite tunes while commuting to work, trekking across campus, or working out, then having the right digital music player is essential. Here are six seven tips to help you find the digital music player that's right for you:

1. Understand the basics.

For the klutz, a player that uses flash memory to store music has distinct advantages over a player that uses a hard drive. Simply put, flash memory players have no moving parts, meaning that you can drop them and not worry about damaging a hard drive - even if you do damage the rest of the player.

For the forgetful, a player that uses flash memory has another advantage - it's more likely to survive a trip through the laundry than a player with a delicate hard drive. No promises here, but survival chances are better.

Those stupid hard drive iPods digital music players are just sooooo delicate that they'd never survive a drop. If you're an active person, a klutz, or absent-minded, think flash memory. Hard drives are for wimps - or at least people who are going to take very good care of their hardware.

2. Make sure you're getting all the goodies.

Many digital music players can do more than just play music. Some can sync with your personal calendar and your address book. Some can be used as portable file storage. Some can even store and display your digital photographs.

Why would you want a music player without all this?

Some have a built-in FM tuner, clock, or stopwatch - features that can be found in tiny radios and cheesy wristwatches at any dollar store. Some come with extra accessories like decent headphones or a lanyard.

Some let you add specialized things like voice recording, a FireWire cable, or an FM transmitter so you can listen to your iTunes music on your car radio. Of course, these features come at an additional cost so only those who need these feature have to pay for them.

3. You'll want a display.

When you have hundreds of songs on your player, you really need an easy way to select your music by artist, album, or genre. This is critical if you want to find that one song or artist you really want to hear. You know, like the iPod has, with that wonderful navigation system. (Remember, players under 512 MB just don't hold that much music....)

A display also comes in handy when you're looking for your favorite radio station, which is why most of those crappy dollar store FM radios with headphones are pretty horrid to use. Then again, if you want to listen to the radio, why not buy a cheap radio instead a more expensive digital music player?

If you just want to listen to part of your music collection randomly, there's no point in having a display. If you're busy jogging, working at your computer, or driving around town, you need your eyes and hands free.

4. Let a professional make your next playlist.

Having an FM radio lets you put your player on autopilot as you mountain bike, cycle, or roller blade.

That's what you really want, isn't it? Letting the DJ at your favorite radio station pick the music is the reason you bought a digital music player in the first place and then filled it with your favorite music.

Trust the professionals. You could never create as good a playlist - and just think of all the ads you'd miss out on!

5. Pick the right size for you.

The price of a player will depend on its storage capacity - the more megabytes (MB) of storage it has, the more music it can hold, and the more it will cost. If you're ripping your own CDs, using a player with Windows Media Audio (WMA) support as well as MP3 support gives you the most music per megabyte by using lo-fi 64 Kbps sampling.

Here are some quick rules of thumb for how much music per megabyte you get, depending on the quality of the compression. For FM radio quality 64 Kbps sampling:

 

Capacity	Number of songs	Hours of play*
128 MB	60	4
256 MB	100	8
512 MB	250	16
1 gigabyte	500	32

* How long you can listen before your digital music player plays every song you've installed on it.

If you want better sounding music, you might want to consider 128 Kbps sampling, such as Apple uses in iTunes (if you don't care about quality, why are you buying a digital music player?):

 

Capacity	Number of songs	Hours of play*
128 MB	30	2
256 MB	60	4
512 MB	125	8
1 gigabyte	250	16
4 gigabytes	1000	64
6 gigabytes	1500	96
20 gigabytes	5000	320

Now do you understand why Apple doesn't make low-capacity iPod shuffles. Who'd pay $50-80 so they could carry only four CD's worth of music on a digital music player?

The question is, How much music do you want on hand? If you want your whole music library, you probably won't be happy with any flash music player. But if you just want something so you can take part of your collection on a run or bike ride, that's where the flash players excel.

6. Don't worry about multiple one online stores.

Have you ever been on the hunt for a particular song? Some obscure indie rock tune or rare jazz performance you heard on the radio? If you don't use an iPod, you might have to shop at more than one store before you find the song you're looking for. Having the flexibility to choose from over 1 million tracks of music from multiple online music stores such as MSN Music, Napster, MusicMatch, and Wal-Mart can consume a lot of your time and try your patience.

With the iPod, you only have to check one source - the iTunes Music Store. If they don't have it, you're SOL, and you know it without wasting time trying to find an online music store that just might have that obscure CD available. (What are the odds that one service will have a noticeably different selection from the rest?)

Want Natalie Cole's Unforgettable CD? Forget it! Something by Garth Brooks? You're up a creek without a paddle. The Beatles? Sorry, but they don't want you buying their music from an online music service. Even the industry-leading iTunes Music Store doesn't offer everything you might want, but if they don't have it, you'll discover that pretty quickly. Then it's time to look for a low-priced (maybe previously played) CD....

Some non-Apple online music stores offer subscription services so you can download all the songs you want for about the cost of a CD each month. Just don't forget to pay, or you won't be able to listen to all of those digitally protected files you downloaded to that digital music player.

7. Don't worry about multiple software choices.

Whether you use a Windows PC or a Macintosh computer, Apple's iTunes is the right software for you - and it's free. With iTunes, you can rip your CDs to high quality MP3 or AAC files, buy music online, organize your music collection your way, easily burn your own mix CDs, and even share your music library with up to five other networked iTunes users each and every day.

iTunes even makes it easy to create a playlist just for the iPod shuffle.

Does that make life too easy for you?

PlaysForKeeps

If you buy a device that has the PlaysForKeeps logo, you'll know that you can use it with Apple's free iTunes music software, iPod music players, and iTunes music stores.

Or you can pick the Windows-only PlaysForSure products and be sure it won't work with the world's leading online music service or most popular music players.

Sometimes it pays to follow the crowd.