The Unwritten Rule Behind Apple's App Store Rejections
Tim Nash - 2008.10.02
If you want to work with someone, don't attack or try to take over part of what they think of as theirs. This is a lesson many learn at school.
If you want to have and keep a partner, you make sure that you have their agreement before moving into their area, and anyone signing the SDK and submitting an app to the store is looking for a working relationship with Apple.
The iPhone is the key product for Apple's future. It is the first really successful new computing platform since the Internet. For many, mobile computers like the iPhone will replace PCs.
If someone is given the fart app and embarrassed by it, how does that make them feel about the iPhone?
If they are embarrassed in a professional gathering, the consequences will be even worse. At the very least it will lead to even stronger corporate monitoring of the App Store and what is allowed. At the worst it will lead to sexual harassment lawsuits, with the iPhone as a highly publicised part of the evidence. IT departments, many of which don't want to support the iPhone, will then use "problem apps" like this as a further reason for delay.
Netshare from Null River, the tethering app, looks to have been rejected because of the limitations of AT&T's 3G network. The combination of large iPhone sales, an immature network (even in major urban areas), and well publicised connection problems has doomed tethering for the short term. Walt Mossberg of the Wall Street Journal recently said that in the Washington, DC, metro area, AT&T promised to have some 800 towers ready at launch; it delivered 80.
Although it makes business sense for Apple and AT&T to support tethering when more bandwidth is available, clearly selling more iPhones and customer plans makes more business sense now.
Apple wants iTunes to be the distribution system for apps, podcasts, music, and video sales. Clearly Apple has few issues with internet music radio as Pandora, Last.fm, Virgin Radio, etc. all have apps in the store, but as these are run by businessmen, they may well have checked with Apple before writing the apps.
Podcaster provides an alternative download mechanism to iTunes for podcasts. If Apple lets Podcaster on the App Store, then companies with deep pockets and interests in music and video distribution will submit apps that access their stores. When Apple rejects them, a lawsuit will quickly follow, and allowing Podcaster risks weakening Apple's defense. Even if Apple successfully defends the rejection, the court may impose restrictions on what Apple can reject. Far better (and cheaper) for Apple to reject Podcaster.
At the end, let's remember this is business. Apple decided not to promote Podcaster through the App Store because it already offered a way of downloading podcasts. The author decided he had more to gain from the publicity surrounding the rejection than by reworking Podcaster. He then used iPhone certificates designed for beta testing to distribute hundreds of copies of Podcaster while asking for $9.99 per copy.
Apple issuing a set of rules for developers could only help those developers unwilling to apply the unwritten law. That is, help until a developer either decides the rules are unreasonable or that the rejection was not covered by the rules.
America is a litigious society. Nearly every quarter Apple has to defend an increasing number of lawsuits despite others being settled. This is a consequence of lawyers going where the money is - and Apple has over $20 billion in cash and short term investments.
A published set of rules would give lawyers another way of trying to get their hooks into that cash mountain. If they succeed, Apple could look at reducing the 70% developers receive from the App Store to cover settlement costs.
For Apple, the App Store is only a means to the end of selling more iPhones. Like the iTunes music business, it may grow to be usefully profitable.
However, what drives Apple now are the profits from hardware.
Tim Nash is a Director of WattWenn which has a new approach to scheduling the production of TV and movies to make the most of budgets. The views in this article are his own and are prejudiced from spending more years working for computer companies than he cares to remember.
Tim lives with his wife, her website on the area ariege.com, two daughters, a cat, and a dog in the French Pyrenees. He lapsed for a while after the Apple II, but became a Mac fan when his wife introduced him to the Macintosh IIsi. If you find his articles helpful, please consider making a donation to his tip jar.
- Mac of the Day: Outbound Laptop and Notebook, introduced 1989.09. The best known among the early Mac clones.
- Support Low End Mac
Low End Mac Reader Specials
Cult of Mac
Shrine of Apple
The Mac Observer
Accelerate Your Mac
The Vintage Mac Museum
Mac Driver Museum
System 6 Heaven
System 7 Today
the pickle's Low-End Mac FAQ