There has been a lot of hubbub already now about the new iMac
colors, but I realized something today: It doesn't 
matter, at least not to me.
I consider my self a power user. I have a pretty powerful system,
but I would use a new iMac with pleasure. Yes, even the Dalmatian one.
(Which is not, since it's blue, really all that dalmatian-ish.)
However, I have also read a bit about Apple and their new music
strategy. As a musician, as well as someone who relies upon Apple
products (and therefore Apple's continued existence), this concerns me.
I think Apple is going on about it all wrong.
You see, first of all, Apple is betting on MP3s as the music
format. That's fine, in and of itself, disregarding the persistent
gripes from audiophiles about sound quality. However, consider that
most of the time people spend working with MP3s, other than listening
to them, is sitting and waiting for their computer to encode and decode
them. I would honestly be surprised it the 500 MHz iMac encoded more
that 2, or maybe 2.25, times as fast as my trusty ol' iMac 233. That would put it, on
a good day at a moderate quality MP3, maybe at 5x-6x encoding. That's
pretty darn quick, but for $100 less than a new iMac, my "new" 7300 will rip the same CD at 7x or
8x. Plus, since it doesn't go any faster at the lowest quality
settings, I'm pretty sure that's a limitation of the CD-ROM drive, not
the CPU.
The amazing part? My 7300 is actually 140 MHz slower than the
new iMac.
Enter the Velocity Engine
By Apple's own admission, the G4 is superior for any kind of
multimedia work. Even without using Photoshop, I have found that to be
the case. Using a program like iTunes, which is based on SoundJam MP
(my encoder of choice), which supports the Velocity Engine, there is
absolutely no reason that at least one of the iMacs shouldn't have a G4
CPU. The argument for a G4 powered iMac is stronger than ever now, 15"
monitor or no 15" monitor.
Apple is shooting itself in the foot by not going out of the way to
make the music experience as seamless as possible for new users. People
in general, and especially musicians, are a generally impatient
bunch. A G4, even a slow one, would go a long way towards speeding up
the few multimedia tasks (like MP3 encoding) which the computers are
being targeted for, while the rest of the system - the 5400 RPM hard
drive and the 100 MHz system bus - prevent the system from actually
being faster than the G4 towers.
RCA audio in and out on the motherboard would be nice too, but now
I'm just dreaming.
Share your perspective on the Mac by emailing with "My Turn" as your subject.
