Today, I am maximizing the Power Mac G5, with the
2 GHz dual-core Late 2005
version being my test subject. We are going to benchmark the stock
Mac just as I received it and then upgrade it with more memory, a new
hard drive, and an SSD.
Round 1: Stock Hardware
I would like to start this out with some straight out of the box
benchmarking. The G5 came loaded with Mac OS X 10.5.8 Leopard. I ran
Xbench, as it has always been my go to benchmarking software for older
Macs. I also recorded the boot time and the time to launch Photoshop
CS2. Testing video playback was last and totally uneventful with the
2.0 GHz dual core G5 running even 1080p HD with no issues.
Stock 2 GHz dual-core, 2 GB RAM
Xbench 85.14
Boot time 53 sec.
Launch PS CS2 20 sec.
Photoshop Filter test 2:53
QuickTime HD playback smooth
YouTube playback smooth
The Xbench numbers tell a lot
of the story with a paltry 85.14, which is compared to the older 2 GHz
dual-processor Power Mac G5 2.0 (which has GeForce 6800 Ultra video)
being worth 100 points. It turns out the hard drive was to blame with
scores 5% to 115% lower. Boot time was what I call reasonable at less
than a minute. Photoshop always seems to take an eternity to load.
Again, video playback was very smooth.
Round 2: Faster Hard Drive, More Memory
Next up, I installed a 500 GB Western Digital 6 Mbps SATA drive.
Before I could install it, I needed to adjust the jumper on the hard
drive to run at the 1.5 Mbps SATA speed. I installed Mac OS X 10.4.11 Tiger along with the
same applications that were tested on the old drive.
Set Processor Performance to "Highest" in Energy Saver system
preference.
Another thing to do when you get a G5 is set it to performance mode
in the Energy Saver pane in System Preferences. (I initially forgot
this and had to rerun tests - and it makes a difference!) I also
installed 8 GB more memory at this time (for a total of 10
GB).
Upgraded 2 GHz dual-core, 10 GB RAM
Xbench 109.93
Boot Time 46 sec.
Launch PS CS2 16 sec.
Launch Ill CS2 7 sec.
Launch Safari 6 sec.
Photoshop Filter test 2:22
QuickTime HD playback smooth
YouTube playback smooth
Xbench jumped up a great deal with 24.79 more points (29%!). This
was because of the hard drive change, as the memory scores stayed the
same. It looks like replacing your original boot drive is a good
investment. Boot time was seven seconds faster, and launching Photoshop
was faster by four seconds.
Next up was to test Photoshop with my filter test. This includes
running two intensive filters and recording the time it takes to
complete them. The memory and hard drive boosted our scores here with
the memory allotted at maximum 3072 MB (nowhere near our 10 GB, but
better than PS 7). Running my filter package on a 222.5 MB photo only
used around 2.70 GB of memory total.
Round 3: SSD Performance
Time to get busy with OWC Mercury Extreme Pro 240 GB SSD. Man, this
thing is a sexy piece of kit! It literally looks like it's a blue block
of aluminum. I installed it with the Newer Technology 2.5"-3.5"
convertor. This was also a quality piece, which keeps with the design
of the G5 nicely. Installing it was a breeze, as it has no jumpers and
slides right into the G5's second drive location. It also installed
OS X as if it were a mechanical drive.
Right away I noticed how quiet the computer was. The mechanical hard
drive was all I could ever hear with the G5 at my desk side. Anyone
looking for a silent computer will be very happy with SSD drives like
the one tested here. Let's take a look at how it ran.
Upgraded 2 GHz dual-core, SSD
Xbench 131.78
Boot Time 43 sec.
Launch PSCS2 6 sec.
Launch Ill CS2 4 sec.
Launch Safari 3 sec.
Photoshop Filter test 1:56
Things are really speeding up now with Xbench busting out 21.85 more
points! This is faster than a stock 2.7 GHz dual processor G5,
which scores 109.87. Boot time dropped another 3 seconds, and all of
the apps dropped seconds off their time with Photoshop shedding 10
seconds off its launch time. My filter test came in 26 seconds faster.
I was interested in how fast it was at loading apps, and man is it
fast. Most of my applications loaded instantly, and only a few loaded
slowly enough to measure them.
Today I raised the bar for all G5 owners by punching out a 131.78 in
Xbench. That's 45% faster than a stock dual-core G5. This breathes new
life into an aging computer that was phased out long ago.
All of that comes at a cost though. I got my swanky G5s for free,
and you can pick up a dual core 2.0 model like mine on eBay for around
$150 (plus a hefty shipping fee, as the things are heavy). Let's break
down the cost of ownership and upgrades:
G5 $150
500 GB WD hard drive $50*
8 GB of OWC memory $116
240 GB OWC SSD $359
NewerTech Convertor $17
Personally, I would love to have the whole thing and keep this beast
going for another five years - but the total cost of ownership is just
too high. For $692 I can pick up a used Mac Pro. The SSD is dead
silent and blazing fast, but I am afraid that for one, its
bottle-necked by the 150 Mbps speed of the G5's SATA bus, and SSDs are
still too pricey for the low-end market. That said, I will be upgrading
my G5 with the another Western Digital hard drive and 4 GB more
memory (for a total of 6 GB) for $58 after I send the other
upgrades back to OWC. It gives the best balance of performance and
price for a low-end Mac user such as myself.
Thanks to OWC for loaning the memory kits and SSD for testing.
