The Ultimate iBook Review, Part 2
Michael Munger
2001.08.03
At the start of this second part of our review, we would like to go
back to the casing we discussed in the first
part. We want to add that the white exterior is very easy to
damage, especially with scratches. You have to carry the iBook in a
sleeve if you put it in a bag or backpack where its casing could take
some abuse, otherwise the nice shiny white coated computer will lose a
part of its sparkle.
Screen
There is a lot to be said about the new iBook's screen. Size is much
of an issue because Apple had to compromise for reasons of price and
space. Many users think that 12.1" is too small for a new portable's
screen, but as we believe that Apple targets education and low-end
computer buying consumers, 12.1" is the right choice. As we said
in Part I, it makes the iBook small enough to
fit in a backpack. It also makes the unit less expensive than a
notebook equipped with a 13" or 14" display. In our opinion, Apple made
the right decision because of its target market for the iBook.
AppleWorks, which we mentioned in the first
part of this review, ships with every new iBook. We found it to be
a decent, fast, and intuitive productivity software suite.
|
The screen is gorgeous. It is much brighter than we expected. When we
did a side by side comparison between the
Titanium PowerBook and this iBook, the latter
won easily in terms of brightness, sharpness, and contrast. The quality
of the LCD display looks much better. When we looked at both displays
from the side, the iBook's screen allowed us to see more clearly than
the Titanium PowerBook's. Therefore, in terms of quality per square
inch, we believe that the iBook is a clear winner, while the size of
the Titanium PowerBook's screen is decisively superior because of the
extra 3".
The level of brightness found on the iBook did have its
shortcomings. We found that with some desktop pictures, the contrast
was so high that the pictures we wanted to use were unusable as desktop
backgrounds, while they looked just fine with our desktop computer's
CRT monitor. Having seen the same pictures with desktop LCD monitors,
we believe that more work could be done regarding the contrast issue.
Still, we believe that the iBook screen's brightness makes it stand
out.
The 1024 x 768 resolution that Apple has squeezed in has been the
object of much talk. Many have said that their eyes would have a
difficult time reading type (fonts) on a 12" screen at such a
resolution. When we set the iBook up, our first move was to switch to
1024 x 768 to find out what it would look like. In our opinion, it looks
just fine. It makes everything much smaller than at 800x600, but we
found 12-point fonts easy to read.
Even small system fonts did not look as tiny as we expected. On the
other hand, we know that we have rather young and excellent sight, so
we cannot judge for people who may have a harder time distinguishing
text than we do. Still, we felt that the 1024 x 768 resolution coupled
with a 12" screen is a good compromise between display space and
readability.
As for acceleration, we found graphics to be rather decent. Of
course, game playing was not as zippy as on our G4 desktop setup, but
we can understand the difference in terms of resources between a RAGE
Mobility card and a Radeon board. Avid gamers should not look at the
iBook as a gaming system. For everyday productivity, however, graphics
are fast enough for normal use.
We sometimes noticed delays between the moment when we clicked the
mouse and the moment when menus pulled down or buttons were pressed. We
asked around and found out that our Energy Saver settings could be
responsible for this, since hard disk drive has to spin up before
responding.
Keyboard
The iBook ships with a full-size notebook keyboard. The 78 keys on
our Canadian French model - US models have 77 keys - have served us
well. The tactile feedback felt just right for our fingers to keep
typing without feeling stuck in the keyboard. Of course, the portable's
keys are a bit smaller than those of a desktop model, but having used
nothing but desktop machines before, we were surprised at how quickly
we adapted to the size and got comfortable with it. In fact, using a
desktop's extended keyboard felt huge in comparison. The keyboard
itself passed the test by our standards.
Autonomy
Apple says that the iBook's battery will last up to 5 hours. This
did not prove to be true. Since we purchased our unit, we were able to
get up to 4 hours of productive use from a fully charged battery when
we set the Energy Saver control panel's preferences to save as much
energy as possible. We wonder how Apple could squeeze 5 hours of use
from this battery since we could not even approach 4-1/2 hours.
Multimedia
The first aspect of multimedia that we wish to discuss is audio, and
it starts with a complaint. Although we do not expect miracles from a
couple of tiny notebook speakers, we were still disappointed. We could
not hear every sound that was supposed to be played. When starting up
the iBook, we sometimes heard the startup chimes, but sometimes we did
not. During everyday use, we did not always hear alert sounds and
sounds related to instant messaging. Apply this to all spontaneous
sounds, and you have relatively poor audio.
Playing music was another story. It seems that the speakers never
quit when the sound is continuous, but as we stated above, ordinary
computer sounds were not always heard. We did not expect the iBook's
speakers to behave like a pair of SoundSticks or Monsoons, but we felt
that they should have delivered each sound that the system tried to
emit.
In terms of audio, we were better served when we hooked up our Sony
headphones to the audio jack. When we did, we missed none of the sounds
that the iBook emitted, and we definitely enjoyed listening to music
with iTunes. Everything sounded clear with the headphones hooked up,
and iTunes, which ships with the computer, is definitely a home run in
terms of usability.
iTunes is a very nice application to handle music.
QuickTime videos were especially nice to play. The screen's quality
has made video images look almost as good as on a desktop setup's
monitor.
We will networking in the third part of our review instead of this
second part. Stay tuned.
The Ultimate iBook Review
Michael
Munger is a French Canadian living in Montreal. He discovered the
Mac in 1994 while studying journalism, the profession he loves and
practices. He also studied history and communications. He writes
iBasicsfor Low End Mac, On the Flip Side for
The Mac Observer, and cofounded MacSoldiersin 1998.
